Hi Manu,
First of all, thank you for all your hard work on Tennis Elbow 4. I think the game has an excellent physics engine, particularly in terms of ball behavior, player movement, and the overall feel of hitting the ball. It is probably the most convincing tennis simulation I've played so far.
However, after spending some time playing the career mode as a WTA player, I've noticed a couple of things that make the gameplay feel somewhat less realistic to me:
1. Changing shot direction seems too easy. In real professional tennis, especially in WTA matches, redirecting a fast or deep cross-court shot down the line is quite difficult. It requires good positioning, timing, and body balance. Even professional players frequently make unforced errors when attempting such shots, particularly when they are stretched or hitting on the move. In TE4, however, changing direction seems relatively easy, even under pressure, and players can often redirect the ball accurately without much additional risk.
2. There seem to be too few unforced errors, particularly long shots. Even when players attempt aggressive shots or repeatedly change direction during baseline rallies, they rarely hit the ball long. As a result, rallies can sometimes feel overly consistent, with players able to maintain aggressive and accurate shots for extended periods.
3. CPU tactical decision-making could be more realistic. I feel the CPU could do a better job of considering the risks of changing direction, especially when receiving a fast or deep shot or when hitting while off balance. In real matches, players often choose to play a safer cross-court shot rather than attempt a risky down-the-line winner from a difficult position.
I wonder whether the risk of changing direction could be more strongly influenced by factors such as incoming ball speed and depth, player positioning, balance, and the angle of the direction change. This might also help create a more realistic distribution of unforced errors.
Of course, I understand that balancing realism and playability is not easy, and I really appreciate the tremendous work that has gone into this game. I just wanted to share these observations, as I think improving these aspects could make the already excellent gameplay even more realistic.
Thank you for your time and for continuing to support TE4!
Best regards
