Do Not Click On The Honey Pot !

gameplay realism / gameplay balance

General discussions about the tennis games Tennis Elbow
Forum rules
Speak English and don't hijack topics, troll, use profanities nor insults

gameplay realism / gameplay balance

Postby uynauxis » 07 Nov 2026, 18:54

Hi Manu,

First of all, thank you for all your hard work on Tennis Elbow 4. I think the game has an excellent physics engine, particularly in terms of ball behavior, player movement, and the overall feel of hitting the ball. It is probably the most convincing tennis simulation I've played so far.

However, after spending some time playing the career mode as a WTA player, I've noticed a couple of things that make the gameplay feel somewhat less realistic to me:

1. Changing shot direction seems too easy. In real professional tennis, especially in WTA matches, redirecting a fast or deep cross-court shot down the line is quite difficult. It requires good positioning, timing, and body balance. Even professional players frequently make unforced errors when attempting such shots, particularly when they are stretched or hitting on the move. In TE4, however, changing direction seems relatively easy, even under pressure, and players can often redirect the ball accurately without much additional risk.

2. There seem to be too few unforced errors, particularly long shots. Even when players attempt aggressive shots or repeatedly change direction during baseline rallies, they rarely hit the ball long. As a result, rallies can sometimes feel overly consistent, with players able to maintain aggressive and accurate shots for extended periods.

3. CPU tactical decision-making could be more realistic. I feel the CPU could do a better job of considering the risks of changing direction, especially when receiving a fast or deep shot or when hitting while off balance. In real matches, players often choose to play a safer cross-court shot rather than attempt a risky down-the-line winner from a difficult position.

I wonder whether the risk of changing direction could be more strongly influenced by factors such as incoming ball speed and depth, player positioning, balance, and the angle of the direction change. This might also help create a more realistic distribution of unforced errors.

Of course, I understand that balancing realism and playability is not easy, and I really appreciate the tremendous work that has gone into this game. I just wanted to share these observations, as I think improving these aspects could make the already excellent gameplay even more realistic.

Thank you for your time and for continuing to support TE4!

Best regards
uynauxis
tennis curious
 
Messages: 4
Gaming Since: 09 Sep 2026, 16:55

Re: gameplay realism / gameplay balance

Postby manutoo » 08 Nov 2026, 07:17

Hello,

thanks for your detailed and thoughtful feedback.

First, could you tell me which difficulty level you're playing at? Pro-10 is the most realistic level, so at other difficulty levels, some aspects of the gameplay may be less realistic.

I think you're right about some of your observations, especially for the WTA.

There are a few things worth explaining:

1) In TE4, women have essentially the same wrist control abilities as men, which can make changing shot direction easier than it should be in some situations. However, making this more realistic would require additional work and balancing, so it's not something I'm planning to change for the moment.

2) More importantly, tennis is an extremely technical sport, and it's impossible to reproduce all its technical challenges accurately in a video game, especially with a limited set of controls.

So one of my design choices has been to make rallies a little longer than they might otherwise be, to preserve the overall spirit and depth of tennis.

For example, instead of allowing a player to easily hit a winner with a single great shot, the game often requires 2 good shots : the first one to put the opponent under pressure, and the second one to finish the point.

This way, some of the technical difficulty that cannot be simulated directly is effectively spread across several shots. It also gives the defending player more opportunities to recover, provided they make the right decisions and execute their shots well.

3) Regarding unforced errors, from Junior-10 upward, players don't make completely unprovoked errors unless they're taking risks with attacking shots.

I hesitated quite a bit before settling on this, but I eventually felt it was a reasonable compromise between gameplay and realism, especially since completely unprovoked errors aren't that common in professional tennis anyway.

So if you're seeing too few errors, it might mean you're not putting enough pressure on your opponents, or that your current difficulty and control settings make it too easy to hit winners.

For example, if you still have the aiming preview enabled, I strongly recommend disabling it once you've learned the basics of aiming.

4) If you'd like to see more errors, you can switch from Simulation to Elite controls. This also affects the CPU players (you can find the setting at the bottom left of your character sheet).

As for CPU tactics, the AI already takes the difficulty of its shots into account when making decisions, although there's always room for improvement.

Overall, your observations make sense, but some of these differences come from deliberate compromises intended to preserve the depth and playability of the game.
ManuTOO
== Mana Games ==

>> I don't answer Private Message, except if it's really a _Private_ topic <<
User avatar
manutoo
Game Author
 
Messages: 21540
Gaming Since: 24 Jan 2004, 15:38
Location: France

Re: gameplay realism / gameplay balance

Postby uynauxis » 08 Nov 2026, 12:35

Hello Manu,

Thank you for your detailed reply! I really appreciate you taking the time to consider my feedback.

I'm currently playing at Pro-8. The reason I'm not playing at Pro-10 is actually that I find the WTA CPU players' shot selection and execution somewhat unrealistic at that level. They often produce extremely sharp, seemingly inexplicable short cross-court shots, with low bounce, which can make their play feel rather unnatural.

Regarding the WTA, I was wondering whether it would be relatively straightforward to introduce a simple tour-specific penalty that makes female players less effective at changing shot direction, or whether this would require substantial work on the game mechanics. Alternatively, is there any way for players to adjust the CPU's overall playing strategy in World Tour mode? For example, could we lower the CPU's "Attack Will" so that opponents are less aggressive and attempt fewer risky direction changes? I think either approach could potentially help make WTA matches feel more realistic.

I also noticed something else regarding serve speed. Even when an opponent has a Service Power rating of around 91, her first serves typically seem to fall within the 160–170 km/h range, and I rarely see speeds exceeding 180 km/h. I understand that 180–190 km/h is certainly not the average first-serve speed on the WTA Tour, but some of the biggest servers can consistently reach the upper end of that range (and i think that player with Service Power rating above 90 should definitely be a good server). For example, Rybakina recorded an average first-serve speed of 182.8 km/h at the 2023 Australian Open.

Given this, do you think the serve speeds in TE4 might be a little conservative for players with exceptionally high Service Power ratings? Or is the actual serve speed more heavily influenced by other attributes, such as height and Service Consistency?

All in all, thank you again for your thoughtful response and for all the work you put into TE4. I really enjoy the game, and I hope these observations can be useful in further improving its realism.

Best regards
uynauxis
tennis curious
 
Messages: 4
Gaming Since: 09 Sep 2026, 16:55

Re: gameplay realism / gameplay balance

Postby manutoo » 09 Nov 2026, 06:06

1) Code-wise, it's not hard to tune the ball change direction for the woman, as it already exists for everybody, but the difficulty would be to get it to the right amount.

2) It's not possible to change the global strategy for all players at once.

3) Women serve speed is tuned for 2015~2020 speeds (when Serena was the fastest server, IIRC).
You can change that with either of these 2 :
- topic15-36838.php
- topic59-5446.php

The Boom Boom talent may also possibly help if the average speed difference isn't that big.
ManuTOO
== Mana Games ==

>> I don't answer Private Message, except if it's really a _Private_ topic <<
User avatar
manutoo
Game Author
 
Messages: 21540
Gaming Since: 24 Jan 2004, 15:38
Location: France


Return to Tennis Elbow 4

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: ClaudeBot, ExaSearchBot, Qindarka, SemRush [Bot] and 2 guests