Hello, Manutoo. I've made a simulation between all styles on Hard (AO) Clay and Grass. Matches were played BO5, Pro 10 , simulation Controls, slow auto pos.
Players were equally skilled on 90 all (top spin being 35 on all). I am posting the results here, if they could be useful for you
(i will personally used them to create more realistic players.ini for the world tour. Haven simulated on US Open , because i feel its still Hard and more or less similar to AO hard.https://ws.eniblo.com/bBF06sdAUZyCZsAnqn/
- Australian Open (hard results)https://ws.eniblo.com/1eIg1gFEemKVf4OraC/
- Roland Garros (clay results)https://ws.eniblo.com/rq4mhwxRQD91cjSRTw/
- Wimbledon (grass results).
Sorry for the annomyous sites, i assure you there are no malwares
Also i've made a whole ranking out of the 3 tournaments (1st for each tournament gets 9 points, 2nd 8 points, 3rd 7 points and so on.)
Puncher - 21 points
PowerBaseliner - 19 points
Counter - 18 points
Bulldog - 18 points
All-Rounder - 17 points
Counter-Puncher - 15 points
All-Court Attacker - 13 points.
Volleyer - 11 points
Deffender - 4 points
I can easily say, Volleyer is pointless (Unless on grass) and Deffender is bad on all surfaces.
Counter-Puncher, All-Court attacker + All Rounder being somewhat in the middle. Never Being top 2 on any surfaces.
And Puncher, Power BS, counter and Bulldog are good for all surfaces (may be excluding grass, on grass results were a bit weird). They were top 2 on all surfaces exluding Volleyer on grass, who got 2nd position.
If u need i could do US Open simulation also, if needed. Just to point out i am using to XKT Mod, so courts arent vanilla, but they use Vanilla Base as much as i know.
Personally i will use only 5 of these styles for the players, because i feel All-Court attacker is quite similar to All-Rounder (watched some 3d matches on normal speed). Same goes for Counter-Puncher, Counter is the better version of the two. Deffender wont be used at all and Volleyer will be used only for a few players like Dustin Brown (no one plays like that, anymore haha).