A couple of questions and suggestions

Everything about this tennis manager game

A couple of questions and suggestions

Postby tsitsitsipas » 08 Aug 2021, 01:56

Hey, I've been enjoying the game a lot, it's awesome and thanks for the work! I had a couple of suggestions that I think might not be too difficult to implement if you think it's worth doing that might improve the realism of the game, and also a couple of questions about a few of the mechanics.

1. How exactly do injuries for AI players work? Do they just retire for one tournament and that's it, or are they out for a while? If it doesn't already work like this, it might be interesting to make it so that they don't participate in tournaments for a few weeks to months after the injury or at least have a minor to major debuff to their stats for a while.

2. I've noticed the East Asian nations (Japan, China, Korea, Hong Kong, Taiwan) seem to spawn players with very dark brown skin which is slightly immersion breaking (but makes sense for other Asian nations like India or in the Middle East), might it be worth making it so that the subgroup of East Asian nations can only spawn players with light skin?

3. Correct me if I'm wrong, but it seems like AI player stats are randomized at the beginning of every year, based on their highest rank and age. I've seen a few situations where a player is very good for 1 year and then suddenly turns into crap the next year once the year rolls over (basically he's awesome in december and then sucks in january), and then he completely bombs out in the first or second round of every tournament he plays. I was thinking it might make a little more sense to make the improvement/decline more gradual over ~4-12 ticks throughout the year, for example every 3 months the player improves or declines by 25% of the original annual change?

4. For player character development, the optimal way to play the game seems to be to exclusively train and only go to big tournaments. Might it make sense for some of the player's attributes to increase a bit when he plays a tournament match, or at least for his abilities to decline less fast when he's playing a tournament as opposed to doing nothing? I think the way you've set it up so that you can only upgrade mental stats with experience is to partially emulate this, but it might be worth slightly improving a player's stats (or at least lessening the normal weekly decline) when he plays a match, similar to how you can train with a practice partner.

5. In regards to career retirement, it seems like players always retire at a fixed age (iirc it's 32 or 33, which is also changable in the settings). I was thinking it might be a better solution to have some kind of formula that determines a chance that a player retires depending on age and rank. For example, a player who is 38 but still top 10 in the world should probably have a less chance to retire than someone who is 26 but has never won a futures match, but still a higher chance to retire than someone who is 35 and still top 10 in the world. Just a hypothetical thought/example, but maybe you could set some ranges for rank and retirement and then set up a formula based on them, here's a very rough example:

Zero chance: Under age 21, Rank 1-10
Very low chance: Under age 24, Rank 11-50
Low chance: Under age 28, Rank 50-200
Medium chance: Under age 32, Rank 200-500
High chance: Under age 35, Rank 500-1000
Very high chance: Over age 35, Rank >1000

With the chance only increasing with higher age/lower rank, maybe using a formula that uses floor/ceiling for some of these values. This way players that are really good will play until they start declining results wise (won't retire when they're still number 1 or 2), and players who suck will retire even in their 20s to make space for newly generated players.

Again, not really sure how much development time these would take or if they're unrealistic, but just a couple of suggestions from my end. Thanks again for the game and being so responsive in the forums, I've had a blast so far!
tsitsitsipas
tennis fan
tennis fan
 
Messages: 13
Gaming Since: 29 Jul 2021, 01:20

Re: A couple of questions and suggestions

Postby manutoo » 08 Aug 2021, 06:02

Hello,

1) It's only for the current tournament ; the debuff is already taken into account for the real years by having a low-rank goal.

2) I'll try to do that some day

3) It must be done all at once else the goal rank will have much less chance to be reached ; it'd bring even more problems for all clay specialists with the clay season being in the 1st half of the year.

4) Only training + big tournaments is close to what most top players do (plus a few lower tournaments), so I don't see the problem with that, especially as it's good to do a few lower tournaments if you get a too big break to maintain motivation, and possibly farm XP to get some in case you have a difficult match.

5) Low-ranked players retirement age doesn't really matter ; plus more retirements = more players = more memory used by the game = not good (saved games are already too big to be sent as Bug Report after 20~25 years). For the real top players, they usually don't retire if they are in the top ~5. I guess the other ones could get a bit more random between 30~36.
ManuTOO
== Mana Games ==

>> I don't answer Private Message, except if it's really a _Private_ topic <<
User avatar
manutoo
Game Author
 
Messages: 18754
Gaming Since: 24 Jan 2004, 15:38
Location: France

Re: A couple of questions and suggestions

Postby tsitsitsipas » 08 Aug 2021, 22:26

Ah ok, definitely some valid points that I didn't consider since I mostly play on fictional years. Obviously not a huge priority, but I think 1 and 3 would probably make the game a bit more "realistic" for fictional years if it isn't too much work, but of course this is just a suggestion as I'm sure you have other priorities. Also 2 more minor things that I thought of:

6. Would it be possible to add wildcards to junior tournaments? I think this is the case in real life.

7. This one is extremely minor, but would it be possible to customize the wildcards? Like for example, in real life occasionally players from other nationalities get selected for a wildcard (like iirc the us/french/australian open all admit one player of the other nationalities as a wildcard), whether its a good performing player or someone coming off of injury.

Thanks for the quick response as always!
tsitsitsipas
tennis fan
tennis fan
 
Messages: 13
Gaming Since: 29 Jul 2021, 01:20

Re: A couple of questions and suggestions

Postby manutoo » 09 Aug 2021, 07:00

6) They are already WC in the Junior Tour ; it works like in the Pro Tour

7) It's complicated to do because if it's just random, it'll look silly... :P
ManuTOO
== Mana Games ==

>> I don't answer Private Message, except if it's really a _Private_ topic <<
User avatar
manutoo
Game Author
 
Messages: 18754
Gaming Since: 24 Jan 2004, 15:38
Location: France


Return to Tennis Elbow Manager 2

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests