The Fall of the Dungeon Guardians
  • Home
    • Home
    • Post List
  • Buy the Game
  • About
    • About
    • Reviews
    • Gallery
    • Video
    • FAQ / Troubleshooting
    • Recommended Computer Specifications
    • Download Press Kit (PR / Screenshots / Logos)
  • Contact
  • Forum
  • Mana Games

Daily Archives: December 29, 2014

Game Design Analysis : Dungeon Master

Posted on December 29, 2014 by manutoo

Dungeon Master Atari Box Art

Dungeon Master – Atari ST Box Art

Dungeon Master - In Game

Dungeon Master – In Game

 

I first played Dungeon Master on my Atari ST when I was a teenager back in 1990.

It was the 1st realtime first-person view RPG Dungeon Crawler game ever, so it was a total blast..! :-P

Although I played it twice till almost the end, I was never able to finish it.

I played it again in early 2009, this time with the punctual help of a walk-through and managed to finish it for the 1st time.

And I just replayed it once more a couple months ago, mainly to get inspiration for the puzzles for Dungeon Guardians. And to my big surprise, there’s almost no puzzle, per se, in Dungeon Master ! There’s something like a dozen of puzzles in total, for 13 levels, and almost half of them are more tricks than puzzles, as they are more about understanding a mechanism than solving a enigma. But in addition, there are also a good bunch of plain text riddles, which is a simpler gameplay concept.

But there are also a lot of “intriguing” zones, where it can get hard to understand where you have to go, what you’re expected to do, and sometimes requires some backtracking. And in that way, the dungeon itself feels like a puzzle, and managing to explore it feels like solving it. This is what is quite unique about Dungeon Master, even by today standards, even when playing for the 4th time, it pours an aura of mystery.

And as I’m not a big fan of puzzles, it’s exactly the kind of atmosphere I’m hoping to recreate in Dungeon Guardians. I’m still designing puzzles, but the complex ones are only to get extra gears & bonus.

Except that, Dungeon Master partly got old. Of course, technically, but also for the fights. They require almost no thinking nor skill, so they get boring after a while, especially the long ones.

But overall,  I think it’s one of the rare games of the 80’s that still offers a gameplay that has not been totally outdated by some better modern games. And strangely, this is partly due to technical reasons : a few years after its release, games started to switch to full 3D movement, instead of the grid-based movement, and although it brings new interesting gameplay, it doesn’t completely supersede the old square by square grinding which keeps its own charm. Another technical point is that in DM, we see 3 squares away ; by today standards, it’s a very short distance. But it helps a lot building the oppressive atmosphere, getting us lost.

That’s all for this classic. In future posts, we’ll check more recent First-Person-View & Grid-Based RPG Dungeon Crawler games ! :-)

FacebookTwitterGoogle+RedditEmailShare
Posted in Game Design | 1 Comment |

Like us on Facebook

Recent Posts

  • Post-Mortem January 13, 2018
  • Afterlife : Updates & Marketing July 10, 2017
  • Gameplay Post Mortem : Meet the Idiots September 3, 2016
  • Technical Post Mortem : Building a game with Unity3D Engine February 21, 2016
  • Final Weekly Update : Treasure Hunt January 13, 2016
December 2014
M T W T F S S
« Nov   Jan »
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
293031  

Recent Comments

  • BabyManuu on Gameplay Post Mortem : Meet the Idiots
  • manutoo on Gameplay Post Mortem : Meet the Idiots
  • BabyManuu on Gameplay Post Mortem : Meet the Idiots
  • manutoo on Gameplay Post Mortem : Meet the Idiots
  • BabyManuu on Gameplay Post Mortem : Meet the Idiots

Categories

  • Development Diary (64)
  • Game Design (11)
  • Marketing (14)
  • Milestone (15)
  • Weekly Update (55)

Archives